Board Thread:Manga Discussion/@comment-28702329-20180621120402/@comment-36933402-20190506083622

Cackleviola wrote: Cackleviola wrote: No he isn’t insane

He is very aware of his actions and he never shows any signs of split personality disorder. Are you talking about Kosaku? Because that is just a guy Kira stole the identity of to stay hidden, he doesn’t actually think he is Kosaku nor does he act like him

Also having a mental illness doesn’t automatically mean that you’re insane. And even if it was he isn’t insane When DID and Paranoid Anxiety Disorder were brought up, people were talking about Diavolo, not Kira. I can see were that might be confusing though, as some people are talking about Kira and others about Diavolo. Zodazzle wrote: Boysmith2003 wrote: Cackleviola wrote: Zodazzle wrote: Insanity does nothing for Diavolo's case. Even if he was insane, that does not make him a better person. If someone creates an entire mafia organization to take over Italy, kills tons of people to save his own identity, and tortures his mother, then any amount of insanity in him doesn't matter. This is about morals and humanity. The same goes for characters like Cioccolata who are also completely insane. Plus. He isn’t even insane He is. He is afflicted with two mental disorders. Those disorders are Disociatvie Identity Disorder, or split personality, and Paranoid Anxiety Disorder. He is therefore mentally ill and cannot be prosecuted. This has nothing to do with prosecution, nothing to do about laws, not even anything to do about punishment. This is about ranking them for how honestly good they are. Even if he has a mental illness, that mental illness has made him the way he is; a murderer and an organized crime boss. He is not good by any means, and his supposed mental illness is to be blamed. Christ, nobody even brought up prosecution because the title doesn't call for legal opinion. At this point, Cackleviola has claimed that Diavolo wasn’t insane(though I believe they were talking about Kira), so to refute that, it WAS necessary to show that Diavolo would be considered legally insane. And even about legal opinions not bent called for, I’d beg to differ. Diavolo is shown to be legally insane, therefore it can be determined by law that he cannot be held accountable for his criminal actions.