Board Thread:Fanmade/@comment-34013154-20181112223306/@comment-38952966-20200221220930

As I've said before, I've no idea how it's even debatable who would win in a direct confrontation. Even Diego with The World (exactly the same Stand as Star Platinum) knew he could not defeat Tusk ACT 4 in direct combat, hence why he had to be tricky and clever during their fight, and even then he doesn't necessarily defeat Johnny as much as he just escapes him. Jotaro would have to pull some Joseph-level bullshit in order to win a fight against Tusk.

That's not to say it's impossible, Jotaro is clever and definitely has a chance, but I don't think it's a very likely one.