Board Thread:Fanmade/@comment-32974074-20180704135153/@comment-31598739-20180704220345

Nabukun wrote: Well basically all you're saying is that you have a little universal checklist you have handy for any work, and that regardless of the creator's style and intents, if there's something that isn't checked, it sucks.

I find the logic extremely faulty. Well that's kind of the whole point. The factors that make something better are usually the same things. And for literature, it's easy to define. World building, character development, designs, creativity, reader enjoyment, etc. People literally create templates for reviews for the sole purpose of touching every subject. We wouldn't have websites like Rotten Tomatoes or IMDB if it wasn't for this "universal checklist". It's kind of like units of measurement, we use them to scale things together. And we can apply this to many things, including the main JoJos. You may not agree with it, but it's a standard for a lot of people that like to take things seriously.