Board Thread:Sandbox/@comment-24031396-20150831180045/@comment-4110939-20151002171712

DK-ALEX-DK (DKDK) wrote: First, i want all the characters from ASB except Baoh, since there is like only 10 characters who haven't returned yet.

As for new ones, i would love to see Keicho and Reimi from part 4. Trish, Secco and Cioccolata from part 5. F.F, Weather Report and Donatello from part 6. Hot Pants and Wekapipo from part 7. Yasuho Hirose from part 8. Some of these are certainly... questionable. First and foremost Reimi. She has no combat abilities whatsoever, and her only "power" lies in her alley, by which she would need to be taken out of to be playable on all stages (and as she's a ghost; It's impossible to have her in anyways because she's already dead). Arnold as her main mode of attack just seems silly, and not even of the 'JoJo' variety. Araki didn't make her a character fit to go into battle, which is why she's only a Dramatic Finish in ASB.

Same with Yasuho, we haven't seen her in combat enough to illicit her face on the roster, and even in the scenes where she is in danger, she has no direct confrontation, same goes for her Stand, which isn't even completely 'obedient'; Paisley Park just comes in to help her out of a near-defeat situation and leaves her stranded until otherwise.

Cioccolatta would require a lot of ability retconning. I mean, his ability is to make mold that eats people in seconds. Otherwise his Stand hasn't been shown in hand-to-hand combat. CC2 would have to completely nerf him relative to the canon to be a playable, even then he'd be an N'Doul-type.

Donatello would also feel like an N'Doul, atleast in the case of placing his opponents in dangerous situations while he sits back and watch. Though his Stand has been shown being proactive, and it'd be sensible to have his ability conjure Stage Hazards that have already happened.

Hot Pants just seems like the character who'd have monotony, as her ability lacks sufficient variety aside from "take your flesh and stick it on your partner".