Board Thread:Fanmade/@comment-34013154-20181112223306/@comment-38952966-20200610193806

I've said it once, I'll say it again: Star Platinum (or any Stand, for that matter) cannot defeat Tusk ACT 4 in direct combat. It is simply impossible. All it takes is one touch and you lose, and while Star Platinum is fast, there's no way he can prevent Tusk from getting at least one hit off. Even Diego with The World (almost exactly the same as Star Platinum) knew he could not defeat Tusk ACT 4 in direct combat.

Jotaro's only hope is to avoid Tusk ACT 4 for long enough to hit Johnny. Problem is, Tusk has a much longer range than Star Platinum, and while SP may be fast, Jotaro is just normal human speed. There's very little chance Jotaro could make it to Johnny without Tusk hitting him, even if he initially dodges it, since Johnny can redirect the rotation.

Diego had a shit-ton of traps and a horse, and he managed to just about escape Johnny. Jotaro has none of those things and you're expecting him to defeat Johnny? It'd be close but Johnny wins more times than he loses here.