Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-39581574-20200711082318/@comment-38952966-20200711192642

See, things get a little muddled with how Made in Heaven works because, according to Pucci himself, the idea of people knowing their fates and getting replaced by similar substitutes can only become permanent if Pucci can complete an entire time loop. Emporio managed to stop that from happening, and since Pucci died before Made in Heaven could complete, the universe was reset again.

In this new universe though, Pucci seems to have never existed. It's left deliberately ambiguous as to whether or not the Stone Ocean Gang are the same people as before, or if Made in Heaven still replaced them. That's up for the reader to decide.

That said, I'd imagine the events of parts 1-5 happened almost exactly if not exactly the same as they did the first time around, since Pucci's existence has no impact on those parts.