Board Thread:Fanmade/@comment-34013154-20181112223306/@comment-38952966-20200825161952

Tusk ACT 4 is not quite as physically powerful as Star Platinum, but it doesn't matter. I've said it once, I'll say it again, and I'll probably have to say it several more times for some of y'all to finally get it: Tusk ACT 4 cannot be defeated in direct combat. Star Platinum is not fast enough to completely dodge Tusk, and any touch from Tusk will spread the rotation to the target.

Jotaro's only chance of winning is to use the time stop to try and avoid Tusk ACT 4 long enough to get close to Johnny. This, however, is very unlikely since Johnny has greater range and mobility, even without his horse. The time stop can help but unless Jotaro has mobility to match Johnny there's not much he can do.

Diego had a horse, and spent a large portion of his fight simply dodging Johnny's attacks, and even then I wouldn't say Diego defeated Johnny; more that he escaped from Johnny. Jotaro is horseless and can't get close to Johnny without exposing himself to Tusk.

I won't say a Jotaro victory is impossible but I will say it's far more likely that Johnny would win the fight.