Board Thread:Fanmade/@comment-34013154-20181112223306/@comment-38952966-20190928214519

JosephFanboy wrote: For one, Jotaro can dodge nail bullets fairly easily, given time stop as well as the fact that Star Platinum is above the speed of light. Johnny shooting a few bullets means nothing, because unless thay are the nails, then Star Platinum can catch it. If it is, he can dodge. Also, ACT 4 can only move for an instant during time stop. Not infinitely. If Star Platinum is damaged due to Jotaro cutting of a hand, (not an arm, because the only way a nail bullet hits is if SP:TW catches it, because he's over the speed of light) then he just kills Johnny slightly slower. Still only takes one punch to donut Johnny. Unless Tusk ACT 4 is right next to Johnny, then Johnny dies immediately. The thing is, after Jotaro dodges a bullet or 2, then Johnny will send Tusk ACT 4 after him, and then Jotaro stops time and blitzes Johnny, while avoiding Tusk.

I don't really trust that Star Platinum is faster than light, because if he was he would've easily been able to beat Made In Heaven, but even disregarding that, assuming Star Platinum is fast enough to dodge a bullet, Jotaro isn't. Johnny would more likely aim at Jotaro where upon Jotaro's only choices are to either block or catch the bullet, or let it hit Jotaro.

It's also greatly out of character for Jotaro to cut off a limb to survive an attack. He'd more likely try to tough it out and find a way to cancel it, like he did during the Yellow Temperance fight.

Don't forget, even if Johnny doesn't directly hit his target, he can redirect the infinite spin through inorganic things, like he did to Diego on the bridge.