Board Thread:Fanmade/@comment-34013154-20181112223306/@comment-34882417-20181126193501

Ability-wise, Tusk DWARFS Star Platinum. Timestop won't do Jotaro any favors, as mentioned above, and he'll instantly lose if Tusk so much as grazes him. However, I don't believe Tusk even WILL graze him.

Firstly, Tusk's stats (even in ACT 4) are... Well, weak. Compared to Star Platinum, it's inferior in Speed and Precision, and only barely edges out in Range (because of the nail bullets). Additionally, Johnny is effectively an immobile, sitting duck who is BARELY able to walk with ACT 4, and needs to use his horse to even activate it.

However, another factor to take into account is, simply put, Star Platinum catching bullets. As shown in the first Ratt fight, Star Platinum has a tendency to catch incoming projectiles with its bare fingers, and this backfires against it numerous times. It's possible that Jotaro might lose instantly because of that, as Star Platinum would be hit by the infinite rotation if it even touched an in-flight nail bullet, even in stopped time.

Overall, I think there's an equal number of downsides and upsides to each fighter, and the winner would be decided by who does what first. If Johnny fires a nail bullet, Jotaro loses. However, if Johnny instead attacks directly with ACT 4, Star Platinum would probably beat it into the ground.