Thread:WranglerPig/@comment-26871105-20161119110902/@comment-26871105-20161119114336

WranglerPig wrote: See JoJo Wiki:Trivia and http://jojo.wikia.com/wiki/Thread:41718How is a meme informative and holding anything of value? Saying that poor scans, have lead to the creation of a meme, is pretty redundant in itself. While trivia isn't banned, you don't see wikis going around "All memes go to trivia". Same reason why speculation isn't allowed and all that.

If we allow every single YMMV content into the trivia, the body will be larger than the article itself.

Speculations should not be included in the trivia because they are not a part of the actual topic (unless we're talking about titles that intentionally encourages speculation then it's a different matter), but rather it's fan interpretations. Irrelevant things should not be included on the topics' pages. However many things no matter how trivial they may sound, depending on its contexts, can be a part of the topic, because the things we're measuring is their content relevance, not their source or format.

"It just works" is an iconic part of JoJo's fanbase since a good long time ago, alongside the "what a beautiful duwang", "wryyyy", or "even Speedwagon is afraid". All of them are trivia-worthy because it actually matters to the topic at hand to a certain extent. There is no need to explore them, but it should be mentioned in the trivia because those "memes" are probably older than most of us here on this wiki.

The point is not allowing every meme to flood the wiki, the point is the measurement we're using to judge the relevance of a piece of info is highly restricting if not borderlining the elitist side of things already. And that's seriously bad. Filtering information based on its type rather than its actual context is bad management, it only leads to elitism and traditionalism, and we're seeing that here.