Talk:Terunosuke Miyamoto/@comment-93.210.2.42-20150807010712/@comment-26871105-20161118151511

No he didn't do any of the harmful things during his exchange with Yuuya, he merely set them up waiting for Yuuya to willingly trigger them. It was a challenge that both parties know would get bloody, it's a completely different scenario than outright causing harm. If it is anything, it's holding hostages and harming them depending on whether or not their situation favours them.

If you want to claim that harming hostages and attacking the challenger is a demonstration of malice and thus somehow punishable by eternal imprisonment, then think Rohan, who did the exact same things during his intial introduction.

If Rohan could remorsely harm and terrorise people with his Stand for no other reason than his personal pleasure, nearly killed Koichi, hold Okuyasu and Koichi as hostages while putting the former on self-immolation, and insulting Josuke's hair (twice in the same row); and got away with it with a couple broken bones. I fail to see how Terunosuke's treatment is anywhere remotely fair in comparison to Rohan's.

Let's be frank, Josuke was clearly not in his right mind when he did the guy in. It's understandable why he did it the way he did, but it's clearly not justifiable even according to his own standard, because we have a comparison in the form of Rohan right here.

And no, Terunosuke is NOT Angelo, because the former hasn't even killed anybody yet, unlike the latter who's killed way more than a dozen. A potential is not an indication of guilt, it's merely a hidden factor, and it should be treated differently because it's a completely different thing.

EDIT: Now I'm not saying Terunosuke is innocent, however I say his finale is too much of an overkill.

EDIT2: As for Terunosuke threatening to tear up Yuuya's papers (1 of the only 2 times where he actually threatened to kill without it being a bluff, one of them is a bloody challenge as described before, as for the other one), because he was desperate. Desperate people do stupid things, and some of them end up doing what he did. Punishable? Sure, kick them butts or break his limbs. But by the Angelo treatment? No, far too heavy.