Board Thread:Manga Discussion/@comment-28702329-20181029121453/@comment-39923208-20191207002206

ToastedCoffeeCup wrote: VinceC87 wrote: JoJo Goodness Tier List:

1. Jonathan

Goodest of the good. Got himself beat the fr*ck up for a girl he didn't even know, and beat the fr*ck out of his brother for assaulting her. Also gave that same brother the benefit of the doubt, seeing the possible good in him, even though it would cost him his dad's as well as eventually his own and his descendants' lives. And best of all, he didn't even need a Stand to do it.

2. Josuke (Part 4)

Pretty dang good boy. Has the power to fix things, which, according to Jotaro (a not-so-nice guy) "is kinder than anything else." When he meets Jotaro and learns he's the bastard son of Joseph Joestar, he immediately apologizes for the ruckus he felt he'd caused, even though there wasn't any way it could have been his fault. Tries to "fix" his dead grandpa, and when he fails, he cries (only the best men cry) and swears to protect Morioh in his stead. Heals Okuyasu after he gets shot in the face, just because he felt like it was the right thing to do. Never kills anyone, only retires them (Angelo/Aqua Necklace, Terunosuke Miyamoto/Enigma). Doesn't flirt relentlessly like his father, but is flattered by complements from women and doesn't tell them to shut up.

3. Joseph

Ok, Ok. I know what you're thinking. ''Joseph's a pervert!!! How could he place so high? That's impossible!'' Well, what you didn't think of was how he almost sacrificed himself in order to save the world from Ultimate Kars. He almost died launching the ultimate lifeform into space. Also, he only kills three people, and they were planejackers. Kars isn't techically dead, and Wamuu and Esidisi are Pillar Men, not people. Also, they wanted to take over the world, so... some pretty hefty stuff right there. However, he's not the goodest because he cheated. Crushing on his mom doesn't count because he didn't know she was his mom. But he still cheated.

4. Jotaro

Here's the turning point. Killed two people, Imposter Captain Tennile and DIO. Believe it or not, Steely Dan somehow survived his beatdown. DIO's death is justifiable because it was to save the world, but you know what isn't justifiable? Calling your mom a bitch. And also not spending time with your daughter. Like, 15 years. In my book, too much love (i.e. Joseph) is a little better than too little love.

5. Jolyne

Another one who tried to save the world. But she kinda died. She also committed robbery to try to get her dad's attention. And it failed. Oops. She also killed a few times. So she's not really good. But there's some good there, I hope.

6. Giorno

Ooh boy. This one's naughty. While his cause is just (to take over Passione in order to get drugs out of the hands of children), he brutally murders anyone in his way. Like, skewer-them-on-broken-iron-lightposts kind of brutal. He kills like 5 people in the first half alone. He kills some dude with his own Stand, turned into a snake. Also, he kills Diavolo repeatedly forever and ever for being The Boss. There's also the part where he steals from innocent women. Kinda rotten.

Jo2k and Johnny never Dude do you seriously have to trash Josuke like that ? And Golden experience resident's ability is to do that giorno the moment he desperately needed to defeat diavolo the arrow him, it gave him the ability he needed to reach his goal and giorno didn't even know what it did he just needed to defeat diavolo. That was a rightfully deserved end to him. Diavolo had tried too end his daughter he hasn't even met for his own selfish desires and he controlled the drug trafficking in his part of Italy leading to the children's use of drugs. Josuke sought to get justice for shigechi he sought to get justice for everyone murdered in morioh. How could they possibly be bad? You've got the wrong Josuke. Jo2k is Part 8 Josuke. Part 4 Josuke is 2nd goodest.

Also, on the scale overall, Giorno can be pretty good, I guess, but he's absolutely ruthless. I need to take that into account.