Board Thread:Manga Discussion/@comment-39718735-20200516000645/@comment-46910799-20200917053448

no, the arrows are not the same, they are completely different, to start Polnareff would not have kept the arrow that had the beetle specifically in it if they were the same,and he was the only one of the 6 arrows on Stand that had a beetle on it, all the others were completely the same design.



the arrow that was used on Pucci in part 6 is exactly the same as in part 5, Pucci only took it back to Egypt and was later recovered by Polnareff and the Speedwagon foundation



Diavolo didn't even know that Polnareff was alive or that he had the arrow, he just went to the coliseum to kill the gang's traitors who knew about his identity,he was still shocked to see that Polnareff specifically had the arrow with the beetle



if he were after a Requiem Stand and the arrows had the same power, it wouldn’t make sense for him to want to use the arrow that was with Polnareff, since he already had a Stand arrow that was used by Polpo,since he is his boss, but he never did, which proves once again that the arrows are different.

Kira does not have a requiem, first it is irrelevant to compare the way the requiem Stands act because it doesn’t change in any way the fact that it was Kira who was pierced, and it was by a normal arrow not by a arrow with a beetle.

no, you don’t necessarily have to be worthy to get a requiem, Black Sabbath didn’t turn the Golden Experience into a reuquiem because that was just a common arrow, Polnareff when he was on the farm there was no reason for him to be worthy of the arrow if he wasn't even in danger, the arrow simply pierced the Silver Chariot and he became a requiem



the King crimsom would rather become a requiem when he was pierced by the Arrow, he was not rejected he would rather become a requiem until he appeared slowly transforming.the transformation was not completed as Bucciarati interrupted before Diavolo could reach King crimson requiem

so yes the arrows are completely different