Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-45543787-20200714223227/@comment-38952966-20200715000747

In a 1v1? Made in Heaven would still win.

Everyone loves to believe that if Jotaro hadn't needed to protect Jolyne, he would've beaten Pucci. And that's partially true. However, let's not forget that Jotaro could only last that long against Pucci because of Anasui. Not even Star Platinum was precise enough to tell when Made in Heaven was about to strike. Jotaro needed Diver Down to help identify when Pucci was close.

In A 1v1, without Anasui, Jotaro wouldn't be able to get the timing right on when to strike Made in Heaven, and ultimately would lose. It's easy for Pucci to weave in and out of Star Platinum's range before Jotaro can do anything, and the longer the fight goes on, the greater of an advantage Pucci has. By the time Jotaro realizes he needs to stop time, Pucci's already out of Star Platinum's range.

I'd say Made in Heaven would win with only moderate difficulty.