Talk:Made in Heaven

This stand didn't seem to be able to change gravity to me, otherwise with such a high rate of time acceleration (a day passing in mere seconds) the gravity of the Earth should've been strong enough to make it collapse into a soccer ball, squashing every single living or non-living thing on it, except for Pucci. Plus, if he could manipulate gravity with this stand, why didn't he use it in combat? I mean, he could've just increased the Earth's gravity to 40 or 50 g to immobilize the good guys then left them lying there to die. And under such a strong gravity, I doubt Weather Report's stand could do anything, since the atmosphere wouldn't be the same anymore. Foreva 06:59, April 13, 2012 (UTC)

Though reasonable to compare this instance with real-life examples of physics, it is crucial to notice that the work is still a work of fiction in and of itself. Include that as trivia for the stand if you will. In fact, there are several discrepancies of this sort especially in JJBA that is still accepted nonetheless (i.e. there isn't enough iron to form that many weapons due to Metallica (if Fullmetal Alchemist is to be taken for truth of human body chemistry in any way, there should only be about 5 g) or the magnetism due to Bast would have affected any surrounding humans so aversely they would've developed health problems due to the charges along their nerves flowing incorrectly). What is important is to keep in mind that this is fiction and that the author's statements, as far as JJBA goes, are fact. TriNiSette 07:05, April 13, 2012 (UTC)

Nah, the article is fine. There's no need for a trivia section. I'm well aware that this manga is a work of fiction and doesn't neccessarily have to conform to the laws of real physics. It's just that this stand is too big of a plot hole for me not to complain a bit about it on this talk page. I mean, C Moon, a lesser stand which was only able to manipulate gravity within a 3 km radius of itself, had obvious gravitational effects on its surroundings such as pulling posts and trees out of the ground and making people feel much heavier. Yet MIH, supposedly the ultimate form of a g-manipulating stand and said to be capable of manipulating the g-force of the whole universe, couldn't reproduce any of such effects. It's like Araki suddenly forgot that MIH was the evolved version of C Moon. Foreva 08:34, April 13, 2012 (UTC)

Point made. You would call that an inconsistency. All that Araki was trying to get at was time acceleration, but in that, he did make an inconsistency. Now that you've found that out, it's up to you as to where to put it. TriNiSette 08:39, April 13, 2012 (UTC)