Board Thread:Manga Discussion/@comment-39718735-20200516000645/@comment-34339581-20200903150517

Calebeto wrote: DewdOfStuff wrote: Calebeto wrote: Daedalus100 wrote: EDIT:You know what, you were just playing with that / this, I think I'm going to enter that little group of yours then; this made me angry Why? I already explained to the guy that both terms "That" and "The" can talk about just 1 object, but he keeps saying that Polnareff is "generalizing" in his lines. I'll tell you, there are situations in which jojofag's are more boring than goku / naruto fans, and this is one of them, I wouldn't mind if it was called boring, but at least I don't use an argument as "generalizing", being that the person may also be talking about just 1 object. Man there are countless arguments that I didn’t use here, like for example in that scene giorno saying: "I will not destroy this arrow";

On this page, Giorno explains to Polnareff that he will not destroy this arrow, so this means that if he did not have this "duty of the survivors", he would destroy the arrow. Now, why was he going to destroy the arrow? think :)

OBS: I admit that, there was a mistake in saying that "the arrow of the pucci ended up in Egypt", I really went to check and, at least in the flashback, there is no dialogue saying that it was ended up in Egypt (and that does not mean that it is not the same, and ended up in Egypt, it may be, it may not be). this doesn't really prove anything, that arrow was closest to him, and it gave him a requiem stand, so he wouldn't destroy it so he could keep it and give it to whoever he deemed worthy of it "so he could keep it and give it to whoever he deemed worthy of it"

Do you know what common sense is? well, a normal person, after seeing that the arrow is too dangerous and cannot fall into the wrong hands, you would normally destroy, duh. However, Giorno did not destroy the arrow because he wanted to "preserve" a reason why Bruno and Narancia died, Bruno gave his life for Giorno to get that arrow, now imagine you give your life to help your friends achieve something, and in the end your friends destroy that item .. One thing that proves even more what I say, is that Polnareff says to keep the arrow inside the turtle (a place that she can be safe), and if Giorno really wanted to give stands that he thinks worthy, he could also use the black sabbath arrow. I will not waste my time here anymore, I just wanted to understand what makes you conspire against something that the anime makes clear (Giorno seeing that the arrow requires is different, polnareff saying that "this arrow is the only way" being that he knows the existence of the others [meaning that really only that is the solution], diavolo holding all 6 arrows and araki having the job of drawing a beetle in just ONE, 1 HURTING Gold Experience stand arrow, while another one is TRANSPASSING King Crimson ...) The only arrow that we saw to give a requiem stand, is the one that contains a beetle in its design (something that is shown even in games), and I will only change my mind when someone shows me a official scene of someone getting a requiem stand with an arrow that does not have the beetle. what do you mean polnareff knew the beetle arrow was the only way, that arrow was closest, and whoever was worthy would get requiem. they didn't have time to fly all the way to another country to get a different arrow

honestly there's not enough evidence for either side