Board Thread:Questions and Answers/@comment-31731691-20190720084039/@comment-44335674-20191115202646

He seriously didn't, I can tell you that right now. Araki doesn't plan that far ahead by and large. That just isn't how he works. But he could have made the Requiem arrow different BECAUSE Gold Experience had already been pierced by a regular arrow

Also, Pucci got Whitesnake from an arrow with the same design. Didn't turn him into a Requiem or create Made in Heaven. Arrows are just arrows all made from the same material. The first comment on the thread talks about what happened with Pucci.

Also I think that person's argument about why didn't anyone get a Requiem after Part 5 is talking about using a regular arrow to give yourself a Requiem, since according to you the Requiem arrow and the other arrows are the same.