Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26949069-20160701200114/@comment-28452300-20161202195000

RajataelSeth wrote: Thehonestone wrote: RajataelSeth wrote: She can be strong and all, but she can't be really ugly, she has to be able to be fabulous. (the clothes don't have to make sense, that makes it more jojoish too).

But that's just visual, the real thing is, all JoJos are kind and loyal. Even Jotaro and Jolyne were actually good. She has to be someone you'd want as a friend and could rely on. That's something Araki made quite clear. I feel that gets rid of her uniqeness.

she is someone you like, but dont want to enconter in real life.

and shes not like, in shape, shes more like 70s arnold in his bodybulider years.

shes deformed, like I said, but not in the "face is shaped wrong" sort.... lets say part of her head is missing entirely and replace with some other stuff.

however, heres something you would like to know: she has two kinda "ticks" in a way, being that she has a tendency to twitch her neck to scrath itches, and her jaw has a tendency to open and close (as if she was chewing food, not that she can do it right)at  random intervals. the way she eats food is like a cow: she moves her jaw in a circlular motion. she does not take a shower naked (cuase it would be more "fan-disservice) but sits in a river fully clothed, and then gets out. she has an odd life ruotine that would make kira clap.

however, her difining trait is that she avoids anything sexual... most of the time.

if she met jonathan (just skip to 11):  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sa5rW_AJw-U I know it has to be unique, but it's possible to be unique and still keep the most relevant JoJo traits, each JoJo is actually pretty unique and still keep those characteristics.

I don't get why making a JoJo part without following that. She could be a good character in another manga, or even a good villain in JoJo, but a protagonist? I just don't feel her like one.

Also, trying to be so non-cliche non-fanservice character makes her feel kinda forced. what makes her "jojo" esqe.

her tendency for outrageously ironic ways of defeating her foes

her habit of bodybuilder poses in victory.

the fact she will use anything in her enviroment as a weapon/disguise. like putting a trashcan over her head as a disguise. or using a... box of crackers as a weapon to strangle a dude